Y: Young Orphan Girls - AtoZ Challenge

The Blogging from A to Z April Challenge is an annual challenge put out to bloggers, to publish a post from A-Z, every day in April, except for Sundays. April 1 is A, April 2 is B……….and so on throughout the month. Participants can post on a chosen theme or publish random posts with no theme at all.

Theme
My theme for 2025 is The Earl Grey Orphan Scheme. I became interested in the scheme when I realised that my great great grandmother was an Earl Grey Girl, who came to Australia as part of the scheme. This scheme was a government sponsored program designed to give young, impoverished Irish girls a chance at a better life in Australia.

A Controversial Chapter in Australia's Past

In 1848, the first of many ships arrived in Australia carrying what would become some of the most hotly debated immigrants of the colonial era - young Irish orphan girls from the workhouses of famine-stricken Ireland. These girls, some barely in their teens, were part of the Earl Grey Orphan Scheme, designed to relieve overcrowded institutions in Ireland, while also helping to balance the gender ratio in Australia's young colonies, and provide much needed domestic servants in the colony.

However, they were not welcomed by everyone. An article published in The Argus in April 1850 captures the storm of criticism about the scheme. It’s a stark reminder of how politicised immigration can become and how harshly vulnerable people can be judged.

The orphans were described by their critics as "stunted," "ignorant," and "unfit for service" - not because they were Irish, the writer claimed, but because they were raised in workhouses without the guiding hand of a mother, or the benefit of a proper upbringing. They were, in the eyes of this newspaper, the worst possible representatives of Irish womanhood.

The article mocks the Irish community’s spirited defence of the girls, painting their support as naïve, misguided patriotism. According to the writer, Melbourne’s Roman Catholic leaders, were ridiculed for insisting that the girls were capable, decent, and simply in need of kindness and opportunity.

I found this article ( source below) uncomfortable reading today, with its heavy sarcasm and thinly veiled bigotry. Yet it offers us, as family historians, vital insight. These weren’t just anonymous passengers on ships like the Lady Kennaway, Eliza Caroline, or Maria—they were real girls, often in their early teens, who had lost everything in the wake of famine and poverty. For many, this migration was their only hope of survival.

Yes, of course some struggled. However, many others persevered, married, raised families, and helped shape the fabric of Australian society. I know this, because my 2x great grandmother was one of these destitute girls, who were given the opportunity of a new life in a new country. Her story is a story of success.

We cannot ignore how harshly these girls were judged, nor should we forget how courageously they faced a new life in an alien land. They were written off by many as "dumpy darlings" and "incorrigibly depraved", but they were also young innocent Irish girls, survivors of famine, and in their new country, the provided many descendants.

They may have been harshly treated by newspapers all over Australia, but history owes them far more than derision. They are owed recognition, and I hope my AtoZ Challenge posts goes towards providing a little recognition so their story isn’t forgotten in time.

Could one of these brave girls be part of your story?
Take a moment to check your family tree for Irish ancestors who arrived in Australia between 1848 and 1850, especially on ships associated with the Earl Grey Scheme. Their names, stories, and strength deserve to be known and remembered.

---

Source: 1850 'IRISH ORPHAN IMMIGRATION.', The Argus (Melbourne, Vic. : 1848 - 1957), 20 April, p. 2. , viewed 22 Feb 2025, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article4766300